Tactics: the art of defending

18 posts   •   Page 1 of 1
Linden Jones' Tash
Member
Posts: 488
Joined: 20 Jun 2009 12:03
Location: north of the river...

Tactics: the art of defending

by Linden Jones' Tash » 03 Nov 2013 11:17

Apologies if this is covered elsewhere, but watching yesterday's performance has crystallised some thoughts about the lack of defensive 'shape' we have when we lose the ball, and I would appreciate the views of tacticians more expert than me on the size of this issue for RFC.

This is all the more poignant as pundits on MOTD have been making comparisons between Atkins and Pocchitino (sic) at Saints and the major shift in number of goals conceded - (for the record, my initial views were that spending £30M on amongst others a decent CB and DM helped, but the tactical insights on MOTD seemed to suggest its also about how they now defend when they lose the ball).

I can't help thinking that our central midfield remains unbalanced and has done since Leigertwood was shown to be limited at PL level. I had hoped that Akpan would be the answer to the 'sitting' midfielder in front of the back 4, but that doesn't seem to be his role.

Is Guthrie the problem? In trying to accommodate him, we have to put up with losses of possession in dangerous areas and don't seem to have a mechanism for coping with quick counter attacks?

Neither Baird, who plays DM as an 'interceptor' type player nor Jem, who does it by buzzing around, (mostly after shadows IMHO) seem to be the answer.

Of course, the back 5 have to take responsibility and Kelly was woeful at LB, but they were left massively exposed.

Surely a team which pays so much on Opta and other technologies should be able to see and address these issues, or is the manager to fixed on a particular approach?

ILoveMoonPig
Member
Posts: 342
Joined: 15 Sep 2013 08:33

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by ILoveMoonPig » 03 Nov 2013 11:50

It's difficult at times to see what exactly our tactics are. I think the majority of Adkins' detractors are so because they were expecting us to play high tempo, short passing, Arsenal style football. Instead, we play a far slower tempo game which is nowhere near as exciting to watch. Add to that, the fact that we all thought we would walk this division, it's just led us all to a general feeling of grumpiness.

Give it a while for our ambitions to lower and eventually this all won't seem as bad

User avatar
blueroyals
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 2153
Joined: 02 Sep 2010 02:11

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by blueroyals » 03 Nov 2013 12:31

When Adkins took over lots of Southampton fans said expect to concede lots of goals...

User avatar
One8Seven1
Member
Posts: 627
Joined: 02 Jul 2013 18:41

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by One8Seven1 » 03 Nov 2013 13:21

Pearce has the speed and turning circle of a tank. Was he worth a bumper new deal to stay? No, I don't think so. Morrison is better but too often goes walkies. We really need a centre-back on loan. QPR did a great job in getting Dunne in! We're missing that calming experienced influence at the back.

User avatar
One8Seven1
Member
Posts: 627
Joined: 02 Jul 2013 18:41

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by One8Seven1 » 03 Nov 2013 13:23

And Kelly should never never never play left-back again. He's always looked poor there, but yesterday was by far his worth performance there. I'm not convinced he's a decent right-back either. Another of McDermott's disaster January signings last season.


User avatar
LoyalRoyal22
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 2608
Joined: 18 Jan 2005 20:06
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by LoyalRoyal22 » 03 Nov 2013 14:03

One8Seven1 And Kelly should never never never play left-back again. He's always looked poor there, but yesterday was by far his worth performance there. I'm not convinced he's a decent right-back either. Another of McDermott's disaster January signings last season.


Yep. Gunter comfortably our best right back.

sandman
Hob Nob Super-Addict
Posts: 12449
Joined: 01 Oct 2008 18:25
Location: Slaughterhouse soaked in blood and betrayal

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by sandman » 03 Nov 2013 14:05

Kelly has been solid whenever he has played at RB and isn't prone to the lapses in concentration that Gunter is prone to or gone missing positionally like Gunter. If we were playing the way we should be ie using our excellent wingers as wide men like they're supposed to be, rather than Adkins awful idea of them going into the centre and the full backs playing as wide men then Kelly would and should be in the team at RB.

Saw Wales lose 0-3 to Serbia a couple of months ago and what side did all the goals come from? That's right Gunter, one was an absolute screamer granted but for the other two Gunter was nowhere to be seen. He is constantly caught out of position and has a nasty habit of misjudging the ball when it's in the air At least when Kelly has played badly he's got the excuse of been played out of position.

User avatar
LoyalRoyal22
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 2608
Joined: 18 Jan 2005 20:06
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by LoyalRoyal22 » 03 Nov 2013 14:35

sandman Kelly has been solid whenever he has played at RB and isn't prone to the lapses in concentration that Gunter is prone to or gone missing positionally like Gunter. If we were playing the way we should be ie using our excellent wingers as wide men like they're supposed to be, rather than Adkins awful idea of them going into the centre and the full backs playing as wide men then Kelly would and should be in the team at RB.

Saw Wales lose 0-3 to Serbia a couple of months ago and what side did all the goals come from? That's right Gunter, one was an absolute screamer granted but for the other two Gunter was nowhere to be seen. He is constantly caught out of position and has a nasty habit of misjudging the ball when it's in the air At least when Kelly has played badly he's got the excuse of been played out of position.


Boring. Gunter one of our most consistent players this season. Last season was left exposed against top players. Had 1 assist yesterday , should have been two. And none of the goals his fault.

paddy20
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1251
Joined: 18 Apr 2007 17:50
Location: Wokingham

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by paddy20 » 03 Nov 2013 14:46

ILoveMoonPig It's difficult at times to see what exactly our tactics are. I think the majority of Adkins' detractors are so because they were expecting us to play high tempo, short passing, Arsenal style football. Instead, we play a far slower tempo game which is nowhere near as exciting to watch. Add to that, the fact that we all thought we would walk this division, it's just led us all to a general feeling of grumpiness.

Give it a while for our ambitions to lower and eventually this all won't seem as bad


Nail on head I think there. we have no tempo which means we rarely expose deficiencies in the opposition as we give them time to organise. In the prem it makes little difference as the defences are far better but in the champ. thats where a lot of our goals came from last time around.. Also our lack of pace at the back means we are very vulnerable when we lose the ball in midfield when we are trying to be creative.


Barry the bird boggler
Hob Nob Addict
Posts: 8153
Joined: 06 Aug 2006 08:34
Location: in my bird boggler

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Barry the bird boggler » 03 Nov 2013 19:44

Class keeper but all four of the other positions in defence could be improved considerably.

Victor Meldrew
Hob Nob Addict
Posts: 6716
Joined: 12 Apr 2005 19:22
Location: South Coast

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Victor Meldrew » 03 Nov 2013 20:13

I think one of our problems is defending from the front.
Pog tries but whoever is his co-striker, whether that be Alf or Kanu, neither is any good at tackling or defending.
Pair that with McCleary and Obita (or Kanu if out wide) and these are two more who are weak in the tackle even if they do track back.
This puts great pressure on central midfielders and the back 4.

Amazingly Brian got both Jimmy and Jobi to do adequate (not outstanding, just adequate) tracking back.
I don't think that any of our back 4 are anywhere near even lower Prem standard so they need the help that wingers and strikers can provide as was the case when Jimmy and Jobi played out wide.
Up until now we have got away with it and apart from the Watford game and now yesterday we appear to be sound defensively-having said that, those of us that watch most games are amazed that others haven't scored more-they have had the chances but at this level are not great finishers.

I fully expect Jobi to be back in on Saturday and do so hope that Kanu goes off to Charlton to join that other under-achiever-how both he and Church have had so many opportunities I'll never know-they must just look good in training.

User avatar
facaldaqui
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1937
Joined: 17 Dec 2004 05:10

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by facaldaqui » 03 Nov 2013 23:13

I think we have had success in recent years with a very defensive midfield that presses and tackles hard. When the opposition have two lines of four to get through, they struggle. Of course, this gives rise to a brand of football that many supporters now moan about, but we made it work with very fast wingers and a fast breaking speed. Now that we are playing with a looser midfield--albeit in Guthrie a more creative one--the opposition can stream forward more easily against us, and this has exposed our lack of mobility at centre back. As for left back, we do pretty well there when Bridge is playing.

Millsy
Hob Nob Super-Addict
Posts: 10022
Joined: 16 Jul 2004 18:36
Location: Running from The Left

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Millsy » 04 Nov 2013 00:36

The problem is the squad.

Shit defenders

Shit midfield

Shit attack

Defenders- Pearce has always been overrated and since when has Morrison suddenly become amazing? A mediocre, slow, cumbersome pair at best and we massively missing Maps. Left back is fantastic with Bridge but when he's not fit we are swpcrewed with no cover. Right back MUST be Kelly who is actually good but for some reason we are doing a Harte all over again and going for a full back who can attack instead of defend.

Midfield - a midfield is shit if it can't defend and with Karacan, Williams and Legs out the picture we are relying on Baird to defend and only Baird. If he doesn't turn up to a game, then we are screwed.

Attack - the best form of defence. We're beginning to learn how to score which is reassuring, but we're not quite there yet. Just as the Pog and Alfie find form and begin to forge a oartnership we go 451 and lose the rhythm. We've just not managed to be a good enough attacking force take it to constitute a good defence just yet.

We need a decent defender not just for cover but serious competition.

We need Kelly to start at RB.

We need a natural LB cover ASAP.


User avatar
Agent Balti
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1332
Joined: 17 Jan 2008 12:39

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Agent Balti » 04 Nov 2013 09:14

ILoveMoonPig Add to that, the fact that we all thought we would walk this division


I think this mind set has lead a lot to the defensive slip ups/cock ups we've shown of late. From the owners down, we were expecting to walk the division, but we're not capable of that. Chopping and changing your left back every other game is not going to help with cohesion of the unit, it's bounds to cause problems...and I think there is a big complacency problem. They're not working hard for each other because they think they are individually better than the rest. Saturday proved this is not the case and hopefully the penny will now have dropped...as if Millwall wasn't enough.

User avatar
genome
Hob Nob Legend
Posts: 25180
Joined: 08 Jul 2012 13:29
Location: Universe

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by genome » 04 Nov 2013 09:36

2 world wars, 1 world cup The problem is the squad.

Shit defenders

Shit midfield

Shit attack


The recipe for success

User avatar
melonhead
Hob Nob Super-Addict
Posts: 14230
Joined: 30 Jul 2010 15:36
Location: on a thorn

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by melonhead » 04 Nov 2013 11:23

weve been worked out.
stop guthrie, and bully our CBs and you win the game.

Pandoras Box
Member
Posts: 512
Joined: 10 Sep 2011 20:12

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Pandoras Box » 04 Nov 2013 12:52

The problem is the squad.

Shit defenders

Shit midfield

Shit attack


Analyse that Pog goal on Saturday and you'll see a positive clinical movement from Guthrie, Baird, Gunter and Pog that made it look piss easy.
If we did it more often we'd have no problems.

Linden Jones' Tash
Member
Posts: 488
Joined: 20 Jun 2009 12:03
Location: north of the river...

Re: Tactics: the art of defending

by Linden Jones' Tash » 04 Nov 2013 19:28

On a related note, I like the thrust of this interview, albeit on a completely different level to our dilemmas, but having watched Reading since the mid '80's, I do think that we are culturally closer to this guy's philosophy than the Rogers and Atkins of this world.

a Klopp style would be a good middle way

http://www.theguardian.com/football/201 ... pp-arsenal

18 posts   •   Page 1 of 1

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], morganb and 384 guests

It is currently 28 Mar 2024 17:31