Longhorn1970 I don't believe that BM was first on their list, I'm guessing the 'sack culture' and the terms of what is prob a 'results based' contract will be off putting for others in the mix, hence the delayed appointment. I think this league is harder now than it was a few years ago and whilst this may be a savvy appointment in terms of uniting the club and getting bums on seats (revenue) it's still lack lustre for me.
Have to agree, if people were underwhelmed at Clarke's appointment then you can certainly feel the same about McDermott's return. I said that if it happened it could be a step back and now that it has I stick by that. Well they do say you should never go back.
Ok so we probably couldn't have got Pearson because of what happened between him and his board at Leicester (Thai owners like ours) plus would he have even wanted to come here? But still I can't help but think we could have got someone better, and there's plenty I would have taken a chance on over McD to be honest, Jovankovic for example? Even Bergkamp, which would have been a risk but sometimes you have to take a chance on those new managers.
It just looks like we've gone for the easiest and softest option without really thinking it through. Are we really going to progress under McD? Based on what we saw before it seems unlikely. His style of football, will it suit the squad of players we've got now? No, I wouldn't have thought so. Only a handful of players still here from when he was last at the club and just one (HRK) that was part of the first team during the last promotion campaign. Mind you it's lucky that McAnuff and Leigertwood aren't still here because if they were McD would start them every game.
I'm not knocking what he did before, he did an amazing job, he got us to the play off final which we lost and followed it up by taking us up as champions with what was a pretty average team. He did bring us some great times but if you remember rightly we weren't actually fun and exciting to watch most of the time, and got even less so towards the end.
I guess its good that he knows the club very well but things are quite different now. He has a better squad this time that is more than capable of promotion, so on paper it should be easier for him to get us promoted. But we know it doesn't work like that, I think he is a fairly limited manager as we saw in the Premier League season, which means even if he did take us back up its unlikely we would stay there under him. In fairness though, we didn't improve the squad anywhere near enough and he was only partly to blame for that.
If he can get the players to play for him, and if he can install some of that confidence, belief and never say die attitude then he has a chance. For now if he can just show us how to win games again I'll be happy. I just hope he has some new ideas and although I'm doubtful about the whole situation at the moment, I'm not writing him off yet.