by Winchester Royal » 24 Aug 2006 08:41
by Platypuss » 24 Aug 2006 08:44
by Winchester Royal » 24 Aug 2006 08:50
by HighburyRoyale » 24 Aug 2006 08:58
Winchester Royal From Reports (I wasn't there ) it appears that Sonko stumbled and the man came down with him.
Not a foul, strictly speaking, but if the man come down in the box after contact with a defender, its a penalty.
Did it stop a clear goalscoring opportunity?
by true blue 4 ever » 24 Aug 2006 09:12
by Forty » 24 Aug 2006 09:14
by UTDSTEVE » 24 Aug 2006 09:22
Forty Decision against us: J lloyd Samuel could very easily have been sent off, therefore he couldn't've been subbed for Whittaker, who produced that magic cross.
by papereyes » 24 Aug 2006 09:33
by igoe agogo » 24 Aug 2006 09:38
Winchester Royal We're back to evens.
Incorrect decisions that benefitted us
Viduka's 'offside' equaliser
incorrect decisions that hindered us
Sonko's red card
Shall I keep this a running thing?
by UTDSTEVE » 24 Aug 2006 09:40
papereyes no - twice.
Angel offside for two well-worked (is that what you meant by good?) goals - good header for the first and a good knock down for the second. But both offside.
As for the penalty - it was a foul. A foul need not be deliberate. He clattered the player as he fell - but there was no intent. Not quite sure what the rules are there, mind. I would say, probably strictly a red.
by papereyes » 24 Aug 2006 09:41
by The Surgeon of Crowthorne » 24 Aug 2006 09:43
by Big Ern » 24 Aug 2006 09:44
Winchester Royal We're back to evens.
Incorrect decisions that benefitted us
Viduka's 'offside' equaliser
incorrect decisions that hindered us
Sonko's red card
Shall I keep this a running thing?
by UTDSTEVE » 24 Aug 2006 09:45
The Surgeon of Crowthorne MOTD showed a late run through by Agbonlahor which was called offside but wasn't. He did complete his run & put the ball in the net but everyone else had stopped because of the flag.
by papereyes » 24 Aug 2006 09:46
MOTD showed a late run through by Agbonlahor which was called offside but wasn't. He did complete his run & put the ball in the net but everyone else had stopped because of the flag.
by papereyes » 24 Aug 2006 09:51
by The Surgeon of Crowthorne » 24 Aug 2006 09:52
That's the one I was referring to - he was onside & had oceans of space. Whilst no one followed him because they saw the flag, he had so much room he wouldn't have been caught anyway.papereyes Sorry, UTDSTEVE - there was a third one wasn't there? Agbonlahor at the end.
That was up the other end and I can honestly say I have no idea.
by Wax Jacket » 24 Aug 2006 09:58
The Surgeon of CrowthorneThat's the one I was referring to - he was onside & had oceans of space. Whilst no one followed him because they saw the flag, he had so much room he wouldn't have been caught anyway.papereyes Sorry, UTDSTEVE - there was a third one wasn't there? Agbonlahor at the end.
That was up the other end and I can honestly say I have no idea.
by TommyF » 24 Aug 2006 10:03
He possibly did, but outside the area. If he sent him off for that then it should not have been a penaltyWax JacketThe Surgeon of CrowthorneThat's the one I was referring to - he was onside & had oceans of space. Whilst no one followed him because they saw the flag, he had so much room he wouldn't have been caught anyway.papereyes Sorry, UTDSTEVE - there was a third one wasn't there? Agbonlahor at the end.
That was up the other end and I can honestly say I have no idea.
he wasn't onside! the MOTD camera was at an angle and so showed him to be level. FWIW I think Sonko tugged Moore back before stumbling over.
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 442 guests