by WestYorksRoyal » 23 May 2025 22:35
by Sutekh » 24 May 2025 06:42
by From Despair To Where? » 25 May 2025 12:06
by linkenholtroyal » 26 May 2025 20:05
by Snowflake Royal » 27 May 2025 07:54
linkenholtroyal Hear me out as I know the addiction issues but…. Aaron Connolly remember seeing him playing for Brighton years ago and expecting him to be the next big name.
Has struggled with alcoholism since and effectively every clubs answer to that is to drop him after a season. Just released by Milwall. Wondered with the right environment and a nurturer like Noel Hunt he is the type of player at 25 could be worth a punt on.
by Brogue » 30 May 2025 10:17
by Hound » 30 May 2025 10:31
Brogue Been told Jayden Wareham has signed the contract.
by WestYorksRoyal » 30 May 2025 10:38
Brogue Been told Jayden Wareham has signed the contract.
by billybraggsbeard » 30 May 2025 10:47
by Hound » 30 May 2025 10:54
by Snowflake Royal » 30 May 2025 12:14
Hound IMO Holmes and TMc just weren’t good enough. I’m sure that’s probably not popular opinion but they always looked to have good potential without ever playing particularly well. They’d do an ok job in div1 but even then I don’t think they’d be a promotion winning pair. Bindon/Mbengue were streets ahead
I’d have Abbey back on loan though. Esp if Mbengue goes
by Stranded » 30 May 2025 12:14
WestYorksRoyalBrogue Been told Jayden Wareham has signed the contract.
Any news on Pereira and Mbengue? Feel like they're the most likely to receive better offers.
by Mid Sussex Royal » 30 May 2025 12:43
StrandedWestYorksRoyalBrogue Been told Jayden Wareham has signed the contract.
Any news on Pereira and Mbengue? Feel like they're the most likely to receive better offers.
Some people playing the ITK game on X are cryptically suggesting we will get confirmation of Mbengue signing today.
No mention of for which club though.
by WestYorksRoyal » 30 May 2025 13:10
by Brogue » 30 May 2025 13:23
by Stranded » 30 May 2025 15:00
by Hound » 30 May 2025 17:40
Snowflake RoyalHound IMO Holmes and TMc just weren’t good enough. I’m sure that’s probably not popular opinion but they always looked to have good potential without ever playing particularly well. They’d do an ok job in div1 but even then I don’t think they’d be a promotion winning pair. Bindon/Mbengue were streets ahead
I’d have Abbey back on loan though. Esp if Mbengue goes
Interesting take, not so much on Holmes and McIntyre, but in comparison to Abbey.
Both players had their issues. TMc mainly being his pace (excluding the injuries) but I think he was otherwise the better defender. Holmes had quality, but was a bit slow, and got too handsy in the box, probably a player most negatively affected by the club's poor performance when he could otherwise have kicked on. I think both more than good enough for this level.
Abbey though, his main attribute was that his pace could get him out of the trouble he repeatedly got himself in by not actually being that good a defender. Obviously experience played a big part in it, but then I don’t think we've seen a lot to suggest he's actually learnt better defending skills since.
by WestYorksRoyal » 30 May 2025 18:09
HoundSnowflake RoyalHound IMO Holmes and TMc just weren’t good enough. I’m sure that’s probably not popular opinion but they always looked to have good potential without ever playing particularly well. They’d do an ok job in div1 but even then I don’t think they’d be a promotion winning pair. Bindon/Mbengue were streets ahead
I’d have Abbey back on loan though. Esp if Mbengue goes
Interesting take, not so much on Holmes and McIntyre, but in comparison to Abbey.
Both players had their issues. TMc mainly being his pace (excluding the injuries) but I think he was otherwise the better defender. Holmes had quality, but was a bit slow, and got too handsy in the box, probably a player most negatively affected by the club's poor performance when he could otherwise have kicked on. I think both more than good enough for this level.
Abbey though, his main attribute was that his pace could get him out of the trouble he repeatedly got himself in by not actually being that good a defender. Obviously experience played a big part in it, but then I don’t think we've seen a lot to suggest he's actually learnt better defending skills since.
Which for Abbey is probably similar to Mbengue - hence would be interested if Mbengue went
Would agree if Mbengue stayed prob no need
by Snowflake Royal » 30 May 2025 18:42
WestYorksRoyalHoundSnowflake Royal Interesting take, not so much on Holmes and McIntyre, but in comparison to Abbey.
Both players had their issues. TMc mainly being his pace (excluding the injuries) but I think he was otherwise the better defender. Holmes had quality, but was a bit slow, and got too handsy in the box, probably a player most negatively affected by the club's poor performance when he could otherwise have kicked on. I think both more than good enough for this level.
Abbey though, his main attribute was that his pace could get him out of the trouble he repeatedly got himself in by not actually being that good a defender. Obviously experience played a big part in it, but then I don’t think we've seen a lot to suggest he's actually learnt better defending skills since.
Which for Abbey is probably similar to Mbengue - hence would be interested if Mbengue went
Would agree if Mbengue stayed prob no need
Mbengue is a long way ahead of Abbey on the ball and has come on a long way in positioning and defensive intelligence. I think Abbey could reach the same level with more experience and good coaching, but it would be a short term step down if we lost Mbengue and loaned in Abbey to replace him. It's a shame we had to sell him as I think he'd have come on great strides in the past 18 months.
by Brogue » 31 May 2025 20:45
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 170 guests