by The Cube »
10 Aug 2016 18:36
10 Aug 2016 18:36
There's a definite problem with the seeding for this draw. Cardiff should be a seed if they beat Bristol Rovers, but Bristol Rovers should not be a seed if they beat Cardiff. And the problem is that that game takes place after the draw. So it seems pretty certain that the winner of that tie will be seeded.
If Aston Villa, Leeds and QPR all win tonight then they will all be seeds and Reading will miss out. If any of the three go out, then Reading will be a seed. Except.... what if Villa win in 90 minutes and one or both of the other two go into extra time? No way would Sky Sports hold up the draw, So again, the winners of any games still going on would have to be seeded.
And all this could be avoided by either:
(a) not having seeds, because it is after all a very stupid system, or
(b) holding the draw after the round has finished.
Note also that Liverpool will play their game away even if drawn at home. They will also pay extra money to their opponents. So Reading as a non-seed and away to Liverpool will suit me.
Edit: Got the "not waiting" bit very badly wrong....
Last edited by
The Cube on 10 Aug 2016 22:36, edited 1 time in total.