BFTG Wednesday.

[windermereROYAL]

Well not much to be said about that borefest. huffed and puffed a lot. clearly instructed to get it in the box early.
The Yorkshire men clearly had just a point and defended very well and we didn't have the guile or know how to break them down.
when we finally created Barrow skied a very easy chance from 8 yards.

Mannone 6 rarely troubles ver calm with ball at his feet.
Gunter. 6 got forward a lot with no end product.
McShane. 7 rarely tested
Moore 7 has above.
Bacuna. 8 MOM for me. always trying to get forward and create.
JVDB 6 solid in the middle, and his hands full with Bannon.
Kelly 5 continues to disappoint.
Edwards. 5 ran around a lot, didn't do much.
Aluko 6 clearly a very skilful player, but need more from him.
Kermy 4 was he out there?
Barrow 5 point deducted for THAT miss.
subs.
Jon dadi 6 showed more then Kermy, but that wasn't hard.
Clement 6 would start him Tuesday,

[RoyalBlue]

Well not much to be said about that borefest. huffed and puffed a lot. clearly instructed to get it in the box early.
The Yorkshire men clearly had just a point and defended very well and we didn't have the guile or know how to break them down.
when we finally created Barrow skied a very easy chance from 8 yards.

Mannone 6 rarely troubles ver calm with ball at his feet.
Gunter. 6 got forward a lot with no end product.
McShane. 7 rarely tested
Moore 7 has above.
Bacuna. 8 MOM for me. always trying to get forward and create.
JVDB 6 solid in the middle, and his hands full with Bannon.
Kelly 5 continues to disappoint.
Edwards. 5 ran around a lot, didn't do much.
Aluko 6 clearly a very skilful player, but need more from him.
Kermy 4 was he out there?
Barrow 5 point deducted for THAT miss.
subs.
Jon dadi 6 showed more then Kermy, but that wasn't hard.
Clement 6 would start him Tuesday,

To claim that Gunter had no end product today is ridiculous. He put in some great crosses with what is supposedly his weaker foot. With a fully fit Kermorgant and/or another decent striker we would have got a couple of goals from them. The likes of Quinn, Senior, Doyle or Long would have been feasting off them.

[Hound]

Fair summary - wouldn’t barely argue with any of those ratings or write up

I’d only say Barrow was worth at least a 7 - even inc the miss (thing he just wrong footed himself - it seemed to just hit his wrong leg). He was our most dangerous player by a distance

Also agree on the poster above about Gunter. Thought he was good today and put in some good crosses

[AthleticoSpizz]

Tackled effectively too

Joey better than his “6”

[leon]

Not sure that Wednesday parked the bus. They were disciplined and compact. They were also pretty poor as well.

This game didn’t really answer any questions for me. The style of football is still not my cup of tea. We’re still not creating nearly enough chances. We looked more solid will with the starting lineup however.

[PieEater]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

[Hound]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

Don’t people basically put up the ratings to debate them? It’s not being rude or moaning, it’s just discussing them

Yeah it’s sad discussing player performances in terms of ratings, but pretty much only as sad as anything else to do with following a football club

And definitely only as sad as people who come onto a football club website and then abuse those people who are doing that

[PieEater]

Sorry Hound but it's lurkers like you that prefer to snipe and pick out scores rather than post an entire alternative perspective. If you have a view to debate then post it, don't pick on Wr for having the time and gumption to post a review that remote Royals might appreciate.

[AthleticoSpizz]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

thanx, love you too.

Why bother giving player ratings in the first place at all, if people cannot give their own?

Bit of a twattish post there from you (of all people) tbf Pie

[Hound]

Sorry Hound but it's lurkers like you that prefer to snipe and pick out scores rather than post an entire alternative perspective. If you have a view to debate then post it, don't pick on Wr for having the time and gumption to post a review that remote Royals might appreciate.

Wouldn’t say I was a lurker exactly

And I basically agreed with everything the first poster said as I mentioned, but gave my view on a couple of the players on the 2 occasions they differed - and quite politely as well, not moaning

[RoyalBlue]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

Look in the mirror when dishing out that insult. Surely the whole effing point of these forums is that it's a debate/discussion?! Follow your warped logic and there will only ever be one post as all agree with that poster.

What's the point of posting ratings if it doesn't matter whether it is rated a 5, 6 or 7?!

And if people really are so precious and worried that someone might criticise their post, they shouldn't be near any form of social media; so probably better they are put off posting .

Of course, calling people complete and utter twats is the way to encourage more posting on threads! (apologies for the knee-jerk reaction back). Fortunately some are more robust than that or these forums would be very empty.

[PieEater]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

Look in the mirror you fool! Surely the whole effing point of these forums is that it's a debate/discussion?! Follow your warped logic and there will only ever be one post as all agree with that poster.

You really don't understand what I said.

I'm not sure there is much point saying anything else.

[AthleticoSpizz]

Yes

[Hound]

you wonder why people don't post when the second third and fourth post are moaning about the first

What does it matter how somebody rates a performance and a 5 a 6 or a 7, get a life FFS.

File these people who debate it under complete and utter twats

Look in the mirror you fool! Surely the whole effing point of these forums is that it's a debate/discussion?! Follow your warped logic and there will only ever be one post as all agree with that poster.

You really don't understand what I said.

I'm not sure there is much point saying anything else.

Yep, agree with that

[PieEater]

Yes

There by ensuring a 2 page BFTG thread

[Old Boy Blue]

I am reliably informed that after failing to pass forward to an unmarked Bacuna and passing backwards instead Paul McShane reacted to the crowds moans by turning towards the Lower West and shouting eff off. Not a great reaction by the skipper of a badly underperforming team.
Did anyone else witness this ?

[AthleticoSpizz]

Yes

There by ensuring a 2 page BFTG thread

try shuffling your original post words up a bit....it might’ve worked better

[PieEater]

Yes

There by ensuring a 2 page BFTG thread

try shuffling your original post words up a bit....it might’ve worked better

My point was, what is the point of shouting down peoples opinions, without posting your own. The only thing it does is stifle discussion and stop people posting opinions from fear of being shot down with people sniping about scores.

[Oilroyal]

Yes

There by ensuring a 2 page BFTG thread

The reason the BFTG is so dull is due to those of us who have been shot down for highlighting how shit this season has been right from the start and now those doing the shooting have gone fishing today

[AthleticoSpizz]

There by ensuring a 2 page BFTG thread

try shuffling your original post words up a bit....it might’ve worked better

My point was, what is the point of shouting down peoples opinions, without posting your own. The only thing it does is stifle discussion and stop people posting opinions from fear of being shot down with people sniping about scores.

oh ok, I just thought that Joey was better value than the “6” that was awarded.....just my opinion,......other than that, I was happy...but I’ll quite happily join the twataraty