SPECULATION - Simion Jackson

[Ian Royal]

You'd have a point if the rest of you were any better informed.

Even you are better informed than Jay.

Says the man whose main contribution to this place seems to be to tell people to keep away

Doesn't stop him being right.

You have a good idea about the limits of your knowledge. Jay has none.

[Sarah Star]

By the same token, it doesn't stop Jay being right either.

If only everyone on here had a clear idea of the limits of their knowledge...but that's what this place is about - imparting your opinion and information to others and discussion whatever your limits Saying someone has no right to do this just because they know less than you (and whose to say you know better anyway) is just wrong... and it really narks me! Who do you think you are? Steve Coppell?

[Ian Royal]

By the same token, it doesn't stop Jay being right either.

If only everyone on here had a clear idea of the limits of their knowledge...but that's what this place is about - imparting your opinion and information to others and discussion whatever your limits Saying someone has no right to do this just because they know less than you (and whose to say you know better anyway) is just wrong... and it really narks me! Who do you think you are? Steve Coppell?

Sarah fancies Jay!
Sarah fancies Jay!

[Platypuss]

[Sarah Star]

LOL at you both proving how much knowledge you have.

Just so I know, are these particular digs aimed at me because I'm female?

[Ian Royal]

LOL at you both proving how much knowledge you have.

Just so I know, are these particular digs aimed at me because I'm female?

No just because you appear to be defending jay rather strenuously, for no real reason I can see.

I like you.

[Sarah Star]

It's not Jay. It's the way people on here arrogantly condemn anyone without offering one shred of evidence that they know any better. This was just the last straw. I actually came here originally to agree with him about Jackson.

No wonder there's so many people who tell me they won't post here.

[Row Z Royal]

As this thread was started by Jay, I can only assume that Simion Jackson is the worst player in League 1.

[Sarah Star]

As this thread was started by Jay, I can only assume that Simion Jackson is the worst player in League 1.

I rest my case

[Ian Royal]

The problem is, over the years Jay has shown himself to know very little, so when after watching a player in a televised match he suggests we sign him he gets a bit of stick. As most people would basing that sort of suggestion on one appearance.

I very very rarely suggest a player we should sign, because a) there's no fricking point me suggesting it to HNA? and b) I don't watch enough football to have a clue about players at other clubs.

I know what gaps we need to fill, but not who to fill them with.

[Row Z Royal]

As this thread was started by Jay, I can only assume that Simion Jackson is the worst player in League 1.

I rest my case

[Sarah Star]

The problem is, over the years Jay has shown himself to know very little, so when after watching a player in a televised match he suggests we sign him he gets a bit of stick. As most people would basing that sort of suggestion on one appearance.

I very very rarely suggest a player we should sign, because a) there's no fricking point me suggesting it to HNA? and b) I don't watch enough football to have a clue about players at other clubs.

I know what gaps we need to fill, but not who to fill them with.

Ignoring RZR for the minute...

I think it's a shame that when he does give some creditable reasons to back his case - albeit on the back of one game seen on the tv - you immediately jump on him for being so presumptious. A bit pot and kettle if you haven't a clue yourself - as you freely admit now.

It is eternally frustrating when you want to know more than you do and people just slam you for not knowing as much as you'd like to.

It has further occured to me that if Deathy saw this guy play for 80+ minutes and you didn't, then really he is better informed than you.

[Ian Royal]

But I've not made any comment about the player's suitability. Because I know nothing about him.