Paul Scholes

[Wax Jacket]

Edgar Davids said much the same thing too IIRC. tbf English footballers are pretty thick

[Big Foot]

a crazy thing called an opinion, pal.

I'm blowing it to bits m8, where's your defence ??

[rfcjoe]

scholesy's medal cabinet > franks medal shelf




can't actually believe you are comparing the two tbh

[Big Foot]

scholesy's medal cabinet > franks medal shelf




can't actually believe you are comparing the two tbh

Honours
West Ham United
UEFA Intertoto Cup: 1999
Chelsea

Lampard and John Terry have won numerous trophies together at Chelsea.UEFA Champions League

Runner-up: 2008
Premier League

Champion: 2004–05, 2005–06, 2009–10
Runner-up: 2003–04, 2006–07, 2007–08
FA Cup

Winner: 2007, 2009, 2010
Runner-up: 2002
Football League Cup

Winner: 2005, 2007
Runner-up: 2008
FA Community Shield

Winner: 2005, 2009
Runner-up: 2006, 2007
Individual
2005 FIFA World Player of the Year: 1

Silver Award
2005 Ballon d'Or: 1

Silver Award
FWA Footballer of the Year: 1

2005
UEFA Club Midfielder of the Year: 1

2008
World XI: 1

2005
PFA Fans' Player of the Year: 1

2005
England Player of the Year: 2

2004, 2005
Euro 2004: Team of the Tournament: 1

Premier League Player of the Month: 4

September 2003, April 2005, October 2005, October 2008
Barclays Player Of The Season: 2

2005, 2006
Chelsea Player of the Year: 3

2004, 2005, 2009
PFA Premier League Team of the Year: 3

2004, 2005, 2006
2004–05 Barclays Merit Award (for 164 consecutive appearances): 1

Premier League's Player of the Decade, (2000–2009) according to official stats: 1[9]

ESM Team of the Year: 2

2005, 2006
FWA Tribute Award: 1

2010

I know m8, Lampard p sses ALL OVER Scholes

[rfcjoe]

If you haven't got the champ league medal in the locker, you're nothing tbh.

[rfcjoe]

or are you gonna copy and past something else to tell me he won another insignifcant award...

[cmonurz]

Scholes - 9 Premier League titles and 2 Champions' League wins, plus a World Club Championship and inducted into the FA's English Football Hall of Fame.

Lampard - 3 Premier League titles, 0 Champions' League wins, no World Club Championship, 0 goals for England in the World Cup, and inducted into Asda's Most Swiss Rolls Eaten In A Minute Hall of Fame.

[Big Foot]

If you haven't got the champ league medal in the locker, you're nothing tbh.

Lampard has scored in a Champ League final, has Scholes?

Lampard is a better player than Scholes, offers more to a team - if United had Lampard last season and Chelsea had Scholes then the title would've stayed at OT

[rfcjoe]

If you haven't got the champ league medal in the locker, you're nothing tbh.

Lampard has scored in a Champ League final, has Scholes?

Lampard is a better player than Scholes, offers more to a team - if United had Lampard last season and Chelsea had Scholes then the title would've stayed at OT

Scholes has won the Champs League once, and was suspended for the other game.

I see you simply resorted to stating your original arguement in the second line there.

You're in need of a ammo reload

http://www.google.com <------ there you go

[Wax Jacket]

I'm fairly evenly split on this one but I think I'll go on the "who's a bigger pcunt" decision, which is obviously Lampard, therefore Scholes is the better player

[papereyes]

Scholes is a ginger asthmatic so plus 1 from me.

That said, I'm also an insufferable fat cunt.

[3 veesinarow]

Lampard has scored in a Champ League final, has Scholes?

A CL winners medal>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>scoring in a CL final.

Ask Frank - he'll tell ya.

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

Scholes>Lampard - somebody poll it.

[rfcjoe]

sheesh. This has got a lickle embarassing hasn't it.

[havoc]

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

Scholes>Lampard - somebody poll it.

coz if awards and goals don't indicate who the better player is, a poll on hobnob sure as shit will

[readingbedding]

Scholes is/was a better midfielder than Lampard was/is/ever will be.

[TBM]

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

Scholes>Lampard - somebody poll it.

coz if awards and goals don't indicate who the better player is, a poll on hobnob sure as shit will

amended

[Row Z Royal]

For me, Scholes just has more class.

[Y21_Royal]

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

^^ this

By that logic Sergi Busquets is better than Michael Essien

[Big Foot]

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

^^ this

By that logic Sergi Busquets is better than Michael Essien

How else would you measure it?

If Scholes is so good, why hasn't he received the individual accolades his team mates have?

[Y21_Royal]

Anyway, talk of the number of awards or goals scored meaning one player is better than another is

^^ this

By that logic Sergi Busquets is better than Michael Essien

How else would you measure it?

If Scholes is so good, why hasn't he received the individual accolades his team mates have?

Personally I think its pretty pointless to directly compare players because it will always be a matter of opinion.

In this case though I think the fact that for the last 15 years Scholes has been pretty much integral to one of the most consistently successful teams in history, trumps any individual awards Lampard's won. He has always been the quiet one that allowed the fancier players like Giggs, Beckham, Ronaldo, etc to take the plaudits.

They are both world class players and if Lampard played for any other side in the world he'd be universally recognized as such.