Stadium naming - where you stand

[Pat Butchers Ring]

im fully behind SJM with keeping the legacy of this great man. he's done wonders for our club and deserves his place in history.

[Friday's Legacy]

the name elm park meant everything. the name madejski stadium means very little to me. at the end of the day naming rights = easy money for the club and that means more investment. that is more important to me than a name over the stadium!

i would though like to see a stand named after him, and perhaps a statue. the latter meaning a lot more than the stadium name.

[1871 Royal]

i would though like to see a stand named after him,.

this for me

[handbags_harris]

Bit ambivolent really. What p*sses me off is there is no identifying feature inside the ground that you're at the home of Reading FC except for blue seats and a small sign above the tunnel. When it was built the stadium was all about Madejski really, hence why instead of "READING FC" or "ROYALS" or "RFC" on in the seated areas you have "MADEJSKI STADIUM" instead.

[Tails]

I think the latter depends on the former, shirley!

[Wimb]

Easy way to make money and I'd rather have a new player then worry about what the stadium's name is. Chances are people will always end up calling the 'The Madejski' or 'The Mad Stad' anyway so not fussed.

Madejski will be remembered as long as this club exists anyway, if the name does change he could always have a suite or a road around the stadium named after him... even maybe a stand.. I suggest the West Upper

[Harpers So Solid Crew]

Easy way to make money and I'd rather have a new player then worry about what the stadium's name is. Chances are people will always end up calling the 'The Madejski' or 'The Mad Stad' anyway so not fussed.

Madejski will be remembered as long as this club exists anyway, if the name does change he could always have a suite or a road around the stadium named after him... even maybe a stand.. I suggest the West Upper

Hurst Way perhaps?

[Terminal Boardom]

Egos aside, when the new ground was named Madejski Stadium, it joined a very select number of grounds that were named after an individual. There was Fellowes Park (before Walsall moved to the Bescot and well before the Mad Stad was built), Ninian Park (named after a local dignatory) and more recently the Kassam in Oxford. I think that keeping the name as the Mad Stad would make a refreshing change from the spread of corporate capitalist greed.

The vast majority of the grounds in this country took their names from a road or are of the town or city obviously before money was king. Very little originality in that. Brentford's ground took their name from the local brewery - the Griffin being the emblem of Fuller, Smith & Turner I believe.

Do we really want to end up like America? Look at the names of their stadia. It makes me shudder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sp ... ing_rights

Whataburger Field anyone?

[Cobi]

It's only a name. I couldn't care either way, but if we can bring in x amount of million(s) per season for another couldn't care less name then IMO we would be foolish not to.

[Terminal Boardom]

I would not be surprised if there was a distinctive age split between those that don't care what the name is and those that are of a more traditional persuasion. I fall quite clearly into the latter group.

[royalp-we]

Egos aside, when the new ground was named Madejski Stadium, it joined a very select number of grounds that were named after an individual. There was Fellowes Park (before Walsall moved to the Bescot and well before the Mad Stad was built), Ninian Park (named after a local dignatory) and more recently the Kassam in Oxford. I think that keeping the name as the Mad Stad would make a refreshing change from the spread of corporate capitalist greed.

The vast majority of the grounds in this country took their names from a road or are of the town or city obviously before money was king. Very little originality in that. Brentford's ground took their name from the local brewery - the Griffin being the emblem of Fuller, Smith & Turner I believe.

Do we really want to end up like America? Look at the names of their stadia. It makes me shudder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sp ... ing_rights

Whataburger Field anyone?

Pizza Hut Park

[Cobi]

I would not be surprised if there was a distinctive age split between those that don't care what the name is and those that are of a more traditional persuasion. I fall quite clearly into the latter group.

Perhaps. It's just a name. Had we been at Elm Park (spiritual home) then I would be dead against it. At the end of the day it is what it is. I never call it the Madejski Stadium anyway. It's just the football ground.

[postwhisperer]

Egos aside, when the new ground was named Madejski Stadium, it joined a very select number of grounds that were named after an individual. There was Fellowes Park (before Walsall moved to the Bescot and well before the Mad Stad was built), Ninian Park (named after a local dignatory) and more recently the Kassam in Oxford. I think that keeping the name as the Mad Stad would make a refreshing change from the spread of corporate capitalist greed.

The vast majority of the grounds in this country took their names from a road or are of the town or city obviously before money was king. Very little originality in that. Brentford's ground took their name from the local brewery - the Griffin being the emblem of Fuller, Smith & Turner I believe.

Do we really want to end up like America? Look at the names of their stadia. It makes me shudder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sp ... ing_rights

Whataburger Field anyone?

Pizza Hut Park

Where is that?

[Magnus]

Frisco, TX

[Pat Butchers Ring]

For me the single most thing I would want to change about our club is the fact we we don't seem to value our identity. Perhaps the poll should have been what is unique about Reading. We don't value our hoops, nickname, ground or even as fans we don't have anything that is unique to us. Everything about us is pretty generic.

[postwhisperer]

Frisco, TX

http://hobnob.royals.org/forum/viewtopi ... a+hut+park

[Friday's Legacy]

I would not be surprised if there was a distinctive age split between those that don't care what the name is and those that are of a more traditional persuasion. I fall quite clearly into the latter group.

i'm also in the latter, however i feel no bond to the stadium or name above its head. at elm park i did. if we can make an extra million a season by having some sponsors name on the stadium then great, why not? it's another decent player coming in, or another 20k a week on the wage budget.

as mentioned, name the west stand after john madejski, stick a statue outside the ground of him arm in arm with steve coppell (picture from leicester). embrace and thank them both in that way. and as per the below, embrace our history and not be ashamed of it as we seem to have been since we left elm park behind.

For me the single most thing I would want to change about our club is the fact we we don't seem to value our identity. Perhaps the poll should have been what is unique about Reading. We don't value our hoops, nickname, ground or even as fans we don't have anything that is unique to us. Everything about us is pretty generic.

couldn't agree with that more. ever since we left elm park it was as if those years we left behind were a dirty word. i'd love to see former players names on the stands, and pride shown in where we came from - no matter how successful we were and weren't. we're proud if it, so embrace it!

[paultheroyal]

It's the Madjeski Stadium for a reason and should remain as such.

[Gordons Cumming]

Elm Park 2.

I don't stand, I sit

HTH

[Ian Royal]

I don't like renaming stadiums. It's been the Madejski Stadium for about 12 years now... that's what it is and what it always will be for me.

As for statues, that's for playing or managing greats once they're dead.

If we're to have any statues they should be of things like Friday shitting in a kit bag, kissing a copper or scoring that goal. Coppell throwing his coat (once he's dead). Murty bundling Kingsley (once he's dead). Death in mid-dive....

Ok, maybe Hammond with a phone in one hand, a massive wodge of cash in the other and a massive grin on his face.