by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 11:44
09 Oct 2018 11:44by Sanguine » 09 Oct 2018 12:10
09 Oct 2018 12:10https://resources.fifa.com/mm/document/ ... eutral.pdfNewCorkSeth wrote:I am a little confused at the moment about the Declan Rice affair. While speaking to a friend about it he informed me that if Rice has put a request to change loyalty to play for England, but never gets capped by England, he will be unavailable to play for Ireland again.
Something about the laws stating you can only switch allegiances once.
This also means that if Grealish were to never play for England he still also wouldn't be able to play for Ireland.
Does anyone knows the laws on this or can confirm whether it is true or false?
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 12:33
09 Oct 2018 12:33by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 12:51
09 Oct 2018 12:51Thanks for the link.Sanguine wrote:https://resources.fifa.com/mm/document/ ... eutral.pdfNewCorkSeth wrote:I am a little confused at the moment about the Declan Rice affair. While speaking to a friend about it he informed me that if Rice has put a request to change loyalty to play for England, but never gets capped by England, he will be unavailable to play for Ireland again.
Something about the laws stating you can only switch allegiances once.
This also means that if Grealish were to never play for England he still also wouldn't be able to play for Ireland.
Does anyone knows the laws on this or can confirm whether it is true or false?
This is true. Or at least, FIFA's laws (page 71, section 8.1) say that a player may 'only once' apply to change nationalities if he or she satisfies all of the conditions. I don't know of and can't find any cases of a player trying to switch back, or switch again.
As to Rice and Grealish, it would depends how you 'acquire' your footballing nationality in the first place. Rice has played for the senior Irish side, I don't know whether Grealish's appearances for each under 21 teams counts as switching.
by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 12:53
09 Oct 2018 12:53Januzaj was eligible for 6 countries.Winston Biscuit wrote:**hijack**
we did a thread years back on creating someone who has the most nations to choose from. Can we do it again? we got to quite a number I seem to remember.
Them being born in Jersey gives them the choice of the 4 home nations. Where else can you be born which makes you eligible for more than 1 nation?
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 13:01
09 Oct 2018 13:01Januzaj popped into my mind as I was typing the above as I knew his was an odd oneNewCorkSeth wrote:Januzaj was eligible for 6 countries.Winston Biscuit wrote:**hijack**
we did a thread years back on creating someone who has the most nations to choose from. Can we do it again? we got to quite a number I seem to remember.
Them being born in Jersey gives them the choice of the 4 home nations. Where else can you be born which makes you eligible for more than 1 nation?
by Sanguine » 09 Oct 2018 13:03
09 Oct 2018 13:03It would come down to whether or not he had to formally switch nationalities in order to represent England U21s, I think. If he has, then he has used up his 'one time'. Would be an interesting test case if he ever raised it though - at this stage I can't see him getting near the England squad.NewCorkSeth wrote:
I thought that too but everyone seems adamant that Grealish cannot play for Ireland even if he wants to. I can't figure out why not.
by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 13:07
09 Oct 2018 13:07And he is one of the few players who could have theoretically played in an international tournament for 2 different teams with the Kosovo thing.Winston Biscuit wrote:Januzaj popped into my mind as I was typing the above as I knew his was an odd oneNewCorkSeth wrote:Januzaj was eligible for 6 countries.Winston Biscuit wrote:**hijack**
we did a thread years back on creating someone who has the most nations to choose from. Can we do it again? we got to quite a number I seem to remember.
Them being born in Jersey gives them the choice of the 4 home nations. Where else can you be born which makes you eligible for more than 1 nation?
So we have Adnan Januzaj being born in Jersey would qualify him to play for Albania, Kosovo, Turkey, Croatia, Serbia, England, Scotland, Wales & Northern Ireland.
If I was him I would have played in an under 21 or friendly match for every one of them while deciding, for the lolz
by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 13:09
09 Oct 2018 13:09If you can get a passport through your grandparents you should be able to get a cap.Sanguine wrote:It would come down to whether or not he had to formally switch nationalities in order to represent England U21s, I think. If he has, then he has used up his 'one time'. Would be an interesting test case if he ever raised it though - at this stage I can't see him getting near the England squad.NewCorkSeth wrote:
I thought that too but everyone seems adamant that Grealish cannot play for Ireland even if he wants to. I can't figure out why not.
my view is that nationality should be limited to country of birth and that of parent's birth. I think it's a silly that Rice qualifies for Ireland through his gramps.
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 13:14
09 Oct 2018 13:14
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 13:18
09 Oct 2018 13:18by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 13:22
09 Oct 2018 13:22I'd love to see a full on Basque vs Catalonia football match.Winston Biscuit wrote:I am also always surprised at how many active Barca players (and others) are allowed to turn out for the Catalan National team in friendlies.
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 13:26
09 Oct 2018 13:26They played each other in 2014 and 2015NewCorkSeth wrote:I'd love to see a full on Basque vs Catalonia football match.Winston Biscuit wrote:I am also always surprised at how many active Barca players (and others) are allowed to turn out for the Catalan National team in friendlies.
by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 13:29
09 Oct 2018 13:29I didn't see either.Winston Biscuit wrote:They played each other in 2014 and 2015NewCorkSeth wrote:I'd love to see a full on Basque vs Catalonia football match.Winston Biscuit wrote:I am also always surprised at how many active Barca players (and others) are allowed to turn out for the Catalan National team in friendlies.
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 13:29
09 Oct 2018 13:29by BR0B0T » 09 Oct 2018 14:23
09 Oct 2018 14:23On a similar lols front I do think NTs that have disputed territory issues should field one player from that TerritoryWinston Biscuit wrote:Januzaj popped into my mind as I was typing the above as I knew his was an odd oneNewCorkSeth wrote:Januzaj was eligible for 6 countries.Winston Biscuit wrote:**hijack**
we did a thread years back on creating someone who has the most nations to choose from. Can we do it again? we got to quite a number I seem to remember.
Them being born in Jersey gives them the choice of the 4 home nations. Where else can you be born which makes you eligible for more than 1 nation?
So we have Adnan Januzaj being born in Jersey would qualify him to play for Albania, Kosovo, Turkey, Croatia, Serbia, England, Scotland, Wales & Northern Ireland.
If I was him I would have played in an under 21 or friendly match for every one of them while deciding, for the lolz
by Sutekh » 09 Oct 2018 14:44
09 Oct 2018 14:44This. Anything else is just plainly ridiculous. Only exceptions would be the crown colony type "countries" such as Isle of Man, Channel Islands etc. which - as they do now - should allow the player to elect to play for any country within the UK.Sanguine wrote:It would come down to whether or not he had to formally switch nationalities in order to represent England U21s, I think. If he has, then he has used up his 'one time'. Would be an interesting test case if he ever raised it though - at this stage I can't see him getting near the England squad.NewCorkSeth wrote:
I thought that too but everyone seems adamant that Grealish cannot play for Ireland even if he wants to. I can't figure out why not.
my view is that nationality should be limited to country of birth and that of parent's birth. I think it's a silly that Rice qualifies for Ireland through his gramps.
by Sutekh » 09 Oct 2018 14:47
09 Oct 2018 14:47Love to see them play Catalunia in Bilbao or Barcelona . Perhaps they could also organise a tournament with Gilbraltar….Winston Biscuit wrote:Basque Country are playing against Venezuela this coming weekend
by NewCorkSeth » 09 Oct 2018 15:19
09 Oct 2018 15:19That's not the law though is it? If they have a Welsh mother and a German father they have to play for Wales.Sutekh wrote:This. Anything else is just plainly ridiculous. Only exceptions would be the crown colony type "countries" such as Isle of Man, Channel Islands etc. which - as they do now - should allow the player to elect to play for any country within the UK.Sanguine wrote:It would come down to whether or not he had to formally switch nationalities in order to represent England U21s, I think. If he has, then he has used up his 'one time'. Would be an interesting test case if he ever raised it though - at this stage I can't see him getting near the England squad.NewCorkSeth wrote:
I thought that too but everyone seems adamant that Grealish cannot play for Ireland even if he wants to. I can't figure out why not.
my view is that nationality should be limited to country of birth and that of parent's birth. I think it's a silly that Rice qualifies for Ireland through his gramps.
by Winston Biscuit » 09 Oct 2018 15:23
09 Oct 2018 15:23Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests