All matches
Championship · 2019/2020
Reading 1-2 West Brom
Home

Match Report

Reading
G Puscas (pen 11)
West Brom
M Pereira (26) K Bartley (49)
Reading may have been beaten by a very good team, probably destined to win this league and certainly achieve automatic promotion to the Premier League, but they should feel proud of the character and determination they showed this evening, especially in the second half. Albion are not the highest scoring team in the Championship without good reason, and from the start they looked likely to score every time they attacked. Reading to their credit were not intimidated by their potent attack and in fact took an early lead through a coolly converted penalty from George Puscas after a bizarre handball by Bartley.

The response from Albion was befitting a team looking to go six points clear at the top of the league and equalised following a typically slick move and sharp finishing from Pereira. Reading were however clearly not going to roll over, and defended with typical discipline and determination. Albion tore into Reading immediately after half time and finally went ahead with a looping header from the Bartley who must have been relieved to have compensated for his earlier moment of madness. Albion’s attempts to disrupt play and waste time throughput the second half reflected the level of respect they showed Reading as they made a commendable effort to find an equaliser. In fact it took a very tight offside decision to deny Meite when he bravely beat ‘keeper Johnstone to Charlie Adam’s superb cross to head into an empty net.

The Reading fans were largely responsible for giving their team a lift by creating a tremendous atmosphere from the kick-off. The game was played at a high tempo from the start, but the fundamental difference between the teams was the quality of the passing and movement. Albion passed the ball quickly and their movement in the attacking third was at times mesmerising, almost telepathic. In contrast Reading looked baffled and hesitant around the edge of the box and opportunities to shoot or pass were lost by an extra touch or a delay in releasing an early ball. Moore and Morrison were solid at the back, Yiadom had clearly not lost any sharpness in the long lay-off due to injury’ and Obita looked far more comfortable in his role at full back and turned in a very mature performance. His delivery from corners were a vast improvement on Swift’s in recent games.

Raphael had a busy night and made some good saves and did well to keep the score down (with the aid of the cross bar on two occasions!) In an early attack a powerful strike got under his body and bounced up onto the frame of goal and away to safety. The game was lost in a torrid opening to the second half when Albion might have scored on at least four occasions in as many minutes. It was like the tide coming in as wave after wave of attacks were launched by Albion. Krovinovic was found in space on the left and forced Raphael get down smartly to save. Robinson found space in the box and hit the bar, and then Barltey nodded Albion ahead at the far post with Raphael in no man’s land. A minute later Livermore swept the ball over from close range. For a while it looked like it could turn into a massacre, but Reading as we have seen this season, do not give up easily, and managed to steady the ship.

Ejaria showed another side to his game using his undoubted skill and strength to play Reading out of tight situations on the left side of midfield and burst forward pushing Albion onto the back foot. His response was commendable. Obita was a solid as a rock alongside him keeping his head under provocation – and yes Albion did, especially Pereira, try to wind Reading up. Swift was struggling throughout with the pace of the game and Rinomhota gave Reading a bit more bite defensively, and pace going forward when he replaced Araruna. Araruna did enough to show he has the qualities of an outstanding midfield player. His touch was sublime and his movement and reading of the game was noticeably sharper than some of his team mates.

As hard as they tried Reading simply did not have sufficient fire power to test Albion’s defence. Only Meite looked likely to trouble the ‘keeper, which shows Bowen might be looking to improve in that area before next season even when Joao is available again. Surely it must be worth considering playing two up front and making room for Rinomhota and Pele in the starting eleven.

I was pleased to hear Mark Bowen talking positively about his team for their efforts in his post-match interview – they had earned his praise. It would have been good for their morale also to receive a bit more from the fans as they trudged off having put in a decent shift against a very good team who not only pass the ball well, but also work their socks off from start to finish.

John Wells

League Position — 2019/2020

Post-Match Fans' Opinion

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 12 Feb 2020 · 10:30pm

    Oh the joy of watching a team defending from the front and hunting in packs. Shame it wasn't us Pele the standout again. That man can mount me any time he wants. Also thought Yaidom did ok coming back in, and Meite put in a good shift. Swift and Ejaria can sit on the bench for a bit. And take Puscas with them

  • JM John Madejski's Wallet 12 Feb 2020 · 10:32pm

    Did their keeper make a single save? Even a lame one? I can't recall one We're just so insipid in attack with Swift and (especially) Ejaria slowing everything down

  • AN Anonymous 12 Feb 2020 · 10:34pm

    Nope, he was completely redundant. Look at the attendances recently, our supporters know that we create very few chances, even against the lesser sides.

  • JA Jagermesiter1871 12 Feb 2020 · 10:35pm

    Find it odd you thought Meite was good and Puscas was poor. For me neither were great but had so little service. Pele was good/ok. Ejaria and Swift awful. Obita, Puscas, Meite ok. Rafael mare first half, fine 2nd. Rest poor to average. Rino made a difference when came on.

  • TR Torbay Royal 12 Feb 2020 · 10:43pm

    Poor performance and whilst some on Twitter are applauding a gritty performance, be under no illusions, this could and should have been a heavier defeat. Pele and Raphael were ok. Ejaria and Swift really need a rest The defence was ok but too much reliance on trying to play out from the back and because the baggies pressed, we were under pressure far too often and lost the ball on a number of occasions. Araruna struggled but he's going to take time to adjust to the speed and style of the english game. Puscas scored a penalty..............and that was it. We were lucky to go in level at half time and never came out for the second… More

  • BP Bristol Paul 12 Feb 2020 · 10:47pm

    Can’t understand the continual insistence on playing from the back. Most of the time Morrison had to hoof it as closed down anyway. May as well kick it long in the first place, at least the players can group in the right place to challenge. Agree with everything you’ve said, unfortunately.

  • WI windermereROYAL 12 Feb 2020 · 10:48pm

    Bed wetters are out in force tonight, get the next two games out of the way then we start playing teams around us, no danger of relegation.

  • LE leon 12 Feb 2020 · 11:00pm

    And that’s our measure of success -having just had a prolonged period of good form including one of our best Christmas periods ever? Really?

  • LW Lower West 12 Feb 2020 · 11:25pm

    Puts into perspective good championship standard players and mediocre ones. Long long way short of being a team capable of challenging for the top 6. WBA looked very good but weren't really. We made it too easy for them.

  • LW Lower West 12 Feb 2020 · 11:27pm

    Wigan is going to be an important game possibly.

  • EV EverHopeful 12 Feb 2020 · 11:30pm

    I find it hard to believe anyone thought we played well........we were outclassed for the majority of the game and probably should have lost by more - cant't be arsed to do player rating apart from these Ojaria _ love him but needs to do his undoubted skill in the right place _ team is guilty of giving him then ball as they are scared defence - all of them - pretty crap. Midfield - so much skill but no enforcer to allow them to do their stuff attack - feel massively sorry for Puscas - he is not a holding player and the sooner Bowen learns the better - he needs a frontman to play off - sadly we haven't got one at the moment. a waste… More

  • GF Gunny Fishcake 12 Feb 2020 · 11:35pm

    The score flattered us, yes WBA are top of the league and a good side, but we were terrible , as we’ve been for a while recently. Bowen has done a good job but his honeymoon is over. The way we’re playing with no threat up front and fannying about at the back and midfield is getting us absolutely no where apart from drifting back to the quagmire of the bottom third of the table, again. We don’t seem the have the fight or desire to simply have a go at teams. If we’re going to lose at least go down fighting. Thousands of fans are voting with their feet by staying away with attendances getting lower by the week . I’ve not a clue what… More

Read all the discussion

Days since This Championship game took place 2397 days ago in the 2019/2020 season. ID: 1340